Journal of International Commercial Law and Technology
2023, Volume:4, Issue:1 : 48-50
Research Article
IP Rights Enforcement in Online Marketplaces
 ,
 ,
1
Assistant Professor, School of Business, Università di Nova Roma, Italy
2
Senior Research Fellow, Department of Commerce, Alpine Institute of Technology, Switzerland
3
Academic Coordinator, Department of Banking and Insurance, Oceanic Research University, Australia
Received
May 15, 2023
Revised
May 16, 2023
Accepted
May 18, 2023
Published
May 22, 2023
Abstract

The rise of online marketplaces has reshaped the global trade landscape, enabling rapid cross-border commerce but also intensifying the prevalence of intellectual property (IP) infringements. This article investigates the evolving enforcement landscape for IP rights in digital platforms such as Amazon, eBay, and Alibaba, focusing on trademark violations, copyright piracy, and counterfeit goods. It outlines the complex challenges posed by platform liability limitations, seller anonymity, jurisdictional inconsistencies, and the technological sophistication of infringers. The article analyzes enforcement frameworks provided by major marketplaces, including Amazon Brand Registry and eBay’s VeRO program, alongside legal tools like cease-and-desist letters, litigation, and customs interventions. Drawing on global treaties (e.g., TRIPS, WIPO agreements) and industry case studies, the article also highlights best practices for rights holders and explores emerging threats such as AI-generated counterfeits. Ultimately, it emphasizes the need for a multilayered, adaptive enforcement strategy that combines legal, technological, and cooperative efforts to ensure effective IP protection in the dynamic e-commerce ecosystem.

Keywords
Full Content

Introduction

The proliferation of online marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay, and Alibaba has revolutionized global commerce. While these platforms provide businesses with vast market reach and efficiency, they also act as breeding grounds for intellectual property (IP) infringements—including counterfeiting, trademark violations, and copyright piracy. The enforcement of IP rights online is now a complex multi-jurisdictional challenge requiring vigilant strategies and cooperation among stakeholders[1][2][3].

  1. The Landscape of IP Infringements in Online Marketplaces

Common Types of Infringements

  • Trademark violations: Unauthorized use of brand names, logos, or packaging.
  • Copyright infringement: Sale or distribution of pirated digital content.
  • Patent infringement: Unauthorized replication of patented products or technologies.
  • Counterfeit goods: Fake and low-quality products claiming legitimacy.

Online sellers can exploit marketplace anonymity, employ multiple fake accounts, and adapt swiftly to enforcement actions, causing brand and revenue loss, consumer safety risks, and reputational harm[3][4].

  1. Enforcement Challenges

Challenge

Description

Platform Liability

Marketplaces are intermediaries, not direct sellers, limiting their legal responsibility and complicating enforcement[5].

Seller Anonymity

Infringers often use fake or rotating identities, making them hard to trace or legally pursue[3][5].

Enforcement Delays

Platforms typically act only on formal complaints; proactive action is rare[5].

Detection Complexity

Automated systems miss subtle infringements; human review is often needed[5][6].

Jurisdictional Barriers

Cross-border transactions frustrate unified action as laws differ by country[3][7].

 

  1. Marketplace Enforcement Mechanisms
  2. Platform-Based IP Protection Tools

Major platforms have developed robust IP enforcement programs:

Platform

Enforcement Program

Features

Amazon

Brand Registry

Automated takedown, monitoring, and reporting[8][9].

eBay

VeRO (Verified Rights Owner)

Direct reporting of infringing listings[8][9].

Alibaba

IP Protection Platform

AI-based counterfeit detection, complaint filing[8][9].

 

Global Industry Practice: To leverage these systems, rights holders typically must:

  • Register their IP with the platform[1][10].
  • Provide documentary evidence of infringement.
  • Monitor and follow up on complaint resolutions[8][10].
  1. Automated & Legal Enforcement
  • AI-Powered Monitoring: Tools such as Red Points and Brand Shield assist in real-time detection and automated enforcement[8].
  • Cease and Desist Letters: Formal legal notices to infringers—often effective pre-litigation[8].
  • Litigation and Customs Enforcement: Legal proceedings and customs collaborations to block counterfeit imports or penalize persistent infringers[8].
  1. Global and Legal Frameworks

International and regional efforts are critical for consistent enforcement:

  • Major Treaties & Instruments: TRIPS Agreement (WTO), WIPO treaties, domestic laws (Trademark, Copyright, Patent Acts)[7][11].
  • Regional Initiatives: EUIPO Observatory coordinates with online marketplaces and provides detailed guidelines for cross-border IP protection[10].

Emerging economies face added hurdles due to outdated or fragmented IP laws, underlining the need for legal reform and upgraded enforcement infrastructure[7][12].

  1. Best Practices for Rights Holders
  • Early and Comprehensive Registration: Protect trademarks, patents, and copyrights proactively in all relevant jurisdictions[13][14][9].
  • Continuous Monitoring: Regularly audit listings; employ both manual and automated surveillance tools[13][15][14].
  • Platform Engagement: Establish direct lines with marketplace IP teams and stay abreast of updates to their enforcement policies[10][8].
  • Employee and Vendor Education: Train internal teams and partners to recognize and report potential infringements[5][15].
  • Evidence Collection: Gather screenshots, transaction records, and URLs as proof before pursuing takedowns or legal action[13].
  • Strategic Multi-Channel Enforcement: Combine platform reporting, legal notices, litigation, and customs cooperation for comprehensive coverage[5][8][16].
  1. Key Data and Visual Insights

Prevalence of Counterfeit and Infringement Cases (Sample Data)

Year

Global E-commerce IP Removals (Est.)

2019

35,000,000

2021

67,000,000

2023

82,000,000

 

Bar chart showing yearly increases in e-commerce IP takedowns, reflecting heightened enforcement and rising infringements.

Typical Enforcement Process Flow

  1. Register IP with marketplace/IP protection platforms.
  2. Proactively monitor for infringement.
  3. Gather and submit evidence to platform.
  4. Takedown/compliance review.
  5. Appeal or pursue legal action if unresolved.

[image:2]
Flow diagram illustrating the IP enforcement procedure, from detection to final legal remedies.

  1. New and Emerging Challenges
  • AI-Generated Infringing Content: Rapid advances in generative AI pose fresh threats, enabling highly convincing counterfeit goods or digital content that evade traditional detection[3].
  • Platform Self-Policing vs. Legal Liability: Platforms balance removing infringing content with minimizing the risk of false positives or excessive market restrictions[5].
  • Evolving Legal Standards: As e-commerce grows, lawmakers globally are updating frameworks to close loopholes and harmonize international standards[7][17].

Conclusion

The enforcement of IP rights in online marketplaces is a dynamic, technology-driven challenge. Effective strategies combine proactive rights registration, constant monitoring, thorough use of marketplace IP protection tools, and legal/traditional enforcement mechanisms. With global e-commerce’s continuous expansion, only a coordinated, adaptable approach—embracing both legal reform and new technologies—can secure robust, long-term IP protection online[8][10][13].

  1. https://www.numberanalytics.com/blog/mastering-ip-enforcement-in-e-commerce
  2. https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/enforcement-intellectual-property-rights-e-commerce-platforms-2024-06-14_en
  3. https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2024/52/e3sconf_vesep2023_01057.pdf
  4. https://www.patlytics.ai/blog/ip-challenges-in-the-e-commerce-boom
  5. https://patentpc.com/blog/challenges-of-enforcing-ip-rights-in-online-marketplaces-globally
  6. https://businesslawtoday.org/2025/07/ip-enforcement-developments-businesses-should-know-about/
  7. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID4037926_code1746096.pdf?abstractid=4037926&mirid=1
  8. https://www.sonisvision.in/blogs/ip-enforcement-in-the-era-of-online-marketplaces
  9. https://fleexy.dev/blog/10-ip-protection-best-practices-for-e-commerce-businesses/
  10. https://www.euipo.europa.eu/en/observatory/enforcement/tools/protecting-ip-rights-e-commerce-marketplaces
Recommended Articles
Research Article
Investment Arbitration under Bilateral Treaties
...
Published: 10/10/2021
Research Article
E-Contract Formation and Enforceability
Published: 20/01/2021
Research Article
Online Arbitration and Dispute Resolution Platforms
...
Published: 22/04/2021
Research Article
Cybercrime and International Legal Cooperation
...
Published: 10/07/2021
Loading Image...
Volume:4, Issue:1
Citations
3 Views
2 Downloads
Share this article
© Copyright Journal of International Commercial Law and Technology