In an increasingly data-driven business landscape, the role of Human Resource (HR) management has evolved from a traditionally administrative function to a strategic driver of organizational success. HR analytics, defined as the application of data analysis and statistical techniques to HR-related data, has emerged as a powerful tool for improving decision-making in HR functions and, by extension, organizational performance. By harnessing data on employee behaviors, recruitment patterns, workforce diversity, and performance management, organizations can derive actionable insights that lead to enhanced productivity, improved employee engagement, and higher retention rates (Fitz-enz, 2010).

HR analytics allows organizations to optimize talent acquisition, retention, and development processes by making data-backed decisions, rather than relying solely on intuition. For instance, predictive analytics in HR can help identify employees at risk of turnover or determine the most effective training programs to boost performance. Additionally, HR analytics provides an evidence-based framework for measuring the ROI of various HR initiatives and aligning these with overall business goals (Angrave et al., 2016).

Despite the growing adoption of HR analytics, many organizations struggle with its implementation due to challenges such as data integration, lack of analytical skills within HR teams, and the complexities of interpreting data to make strategic decisions. This study aims to explore the impact of HR analytics on organizational effectiveness, focusing on how data-driven HR practices contribute to enhanced performance outcomes. Specifically, this research will assess the extent to which HR analytics influences key performance indicators (KPIs) such as employee productivity, engagement, and retention, providing empirical evidence from a range of industries.

Organizations are increasingly leveraging data-driven technologies to optimize their operations and enhance performance. One such approach, Human Resource (HR) Analytics, has gained prominence as a strategic tool that goes beyond traditional HR functions. HR analytics refers to the application of data mining, statistical analysis, and predictive modeling techniques to human capital data, allowing HR departments to make evidence-based decisions (Marler & Boudreau, 2017). By utilizing large datasets on employee behavior, performance, recruitment, and turnover, HR professionals can predict future trends, improve talent management, and align human capital strategies with organizational goals.

In recent years, HR analytics has emerged as a critical enabler of organizational effectiveness. Research suggests that organizations that successfully adopt HR analytics experience improved decision-making capabilities, higher employee engagement, better retention rates, and greater overall productivity (Reddy & Lakshmikeerthi, 2020). Furthermore, HR analytics allows firms to assess the ROI of HR initiatives by measuring their direct impact on key performance indicators (KPIs) such as revenue growth, cost reduction, and workforce efficiency (Bassi, Carpenter, & McMurrer, 2020).

However, despite the potential of HR analytics, there remain significant challenges to its adoption. These challenges include issues such as data integration, analytical skills gaps within HR departments, and organizational resistance to data-driven decision-making (Minbaeva, 2018). As such, while HR analytics presents exciting opportunities for enhancing organizational effectiveness, understanding its practical application and overcoming these challenges is critical for maximizing its benefits.

This study aims to explore the impact of HR analytics on organizational performance, particularly in how data-driven HR practices contribute to key performance outcomes like productivity, employee engagement, and retention. By providing empirical insights, this research will offer guidance for organizations looking to integrate HR analytics into their strategic framework.

Research Objectives

1. To analyze the role of HR analytics in improving decision-making within HR departments.
2. To evaluate the impact of HR analytics on organizational performance indicators such as productivity, engagement, and employee retention.
3. To identify the challenges and barriers organizations face in the effective implementation of HR analytics.

According to Reddy and Keerthi's 2017 paper, "HR Analytics: An Effective Evidence Based HRM Tool," human resources are an organization's most important asset and need more attention. They argue that an evidence-based approach is the best way for a corporation to make decisions, and HR analytics not only supports this but also pushes firms to preserve high-quality data to show the ROI of HR investments.

In their Anshu and Tanuja Sharma (2017) study, "HR analytics and performance appraisal system: A conceptual framework for employee performance improvement,” discovered the function of HR analytics on PA systems and how they affect employees' motivation to perform better by putting forth a conceptual model. Using expert data analysis tools, HR analytics was employed as a solution in this case to improve the evaluation process' accuracy. This report offered some ideas for future research directions to advance performance management, in addition to other presumptions for scholars in this area.

"A study on the measuring the factors of HR analytics on performances management in services sector of selected companies in Chennai," Anita and Sumathi (2019) discovered the ways in which performance management systems affect worker performance. And how employee performance might be affected by the versatile phases of the performance management system? The initial goal is to investigate the relationship between employee performance and the performance management system. Using the WERS 2004 dataset, the second goal is to examine performance management systems and how they relate to employee performance. Finding out how the performance management system and employee performance are related and explicate a list of suggestions are the final goals.

In their study titled "HR Analytics Methodical Measurement of HR Processes," Udhay Kailash and M Prathyusha (2020) concluded that HR analytics is more evidential since it evaluates employees' contributions to the institution, forecasts manpower needs, and connects manpower utilization to strategical goals to enhance business performance. In this instance, the HR Analytics epistemology is widely used in the pharmaceutical business and is replicable in other companies within the same sector.

In their 2020 study, "HR Analytics: A Literature Review and New Conceptual Model," H.D.P.J. Opatha unconcealed that HR analytics offers a data-driven structure for compelling manpower issues by analyzing data using a coalition of software and techniques that apply mathematical models and offer fresh perspectives for more intelligent decision-making that enable managers to maximize human resource management.

In their study titled "The impact of performance management system on employees' performance," (Said et. al., 2021) concluded that management of any firm should modify its performance management system procedures to make them more ongoing. It is recommended that management examine and take into account the issues that employees face, as well as recognize them and assist them in addressing them as a cohesive team. Employers should implement recognition techniques since they will boost staff morale and motivation when they feel appreciated. Employees strive to meet the necessary goals after their efforts are valued and acknowledged. Employers should reward staff for their efforts in achieving their goals and include them in the goal-setting process.

In their research paper "Bridging the gap: why, how, and when HR analytics can impact organizational performance," Steven McCartney and Na Fu (2022) found that because HR analytics is still a relatively new concept, academics are still emphasizing how it can aid in decision-making and the achievement of organizational goals. According to the chain model put forward by this study, having access to HR technology facilitates HR analytics, which in turn supports evidence-based management and enhances organizational performance.

Although HR management software and analytics can offer insightful information, their implementation calls for a large financial outlay as well as specific knowledge. Employers are required to make sure that employee data is handled securely and in compliance with relevant privacy laws.

Additionally, management and staff who might not be experienced with data-driven initiatives are resistant to change (Ramzi & Elrayah, 2021).
A systematic change management approach, training, and good communication are necessary to handle this cultural shift. Thus, even while technology can increase HR management's efficacy and efficiency, businesses must be ready to handle the difficulties that come with putting it into practice.
Many areas, including management, have seen substantial changes since the dawn of the data and analytics era. Data is an invaluable resource that may offer profound insights and direct strategic decision-making in a world that is becoming more digitally connected. Large volumes of data may now be accessed and analyzed by managers to find links, trends, and patterns that were previously invisible.

Data analytics facilitates product development, enhanced customer service, and operational optimization in the management environment (McCartney & Fu, 2022). Data analysis, for instance, can assist managers in forecasting market demand, understanding consumer behavior, and identifying areas for cost savings. Organizations may react to changes more swiftly and effectively with more precise and up-to-date information, increasing their marketability.

A new method of managing human resources (HR) has also been introduced by the data and analytical era. For instance, HR analytics enables businesses to assess and enhance worker performance and pinpoint elements that influence job satisfaction and retention.

HR managers can make more evidence-based decisions by utilizing data from multiple sources, including performance reviews, attendance logs, and employee surveys. Forecasting future hiring requirements, identifying the top applicants, and creating specialized development programs are all possible with predictive analytics. As a result, the data and analytics era not only increases operational effectiveness but also creates new chances for innovation and expansion across a range of management domains (Opatha, 2020).
Prior studies on the application of HR analytics to enhance organizational performance have produced a number of significant discoveries that contribute to our growing knowledge of this subject. Rasmussen and Ulrich's (2015) paper, for instance, highlights how HR analytics can enhance strategic choices in human resource management.

They discovered that companies using HR analytics were much more adept at managing employee performance, determining training needs, and planning for leadership succession. Their results demonstrate that strong analytics capabilities and cross-functional data integration within firms are necessary for effective analytics, in addition to relying on cutting-edge technology. This demonstrates that optimizing the value derived from data requires HR professionals to strengthen their analytical abilities.
Furthermore, the significance of HR analytics in controlling organizational performance is further supported by research by Marler and Boudreau (2017). They investigate the relationship between employee performance data and corporate results, including profitability and productivity, using HR analytics.

According to their research, businesses can forecast turnover trends, pinpoint performance-influencing variables, and create more focused interventions by utilizing HR analytics.

Looking ahead, the future of HR analytics lies in the integration of emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning. These technologies have the potential to further automate HR processes and provide even more advanced insights into workforce trends. For example, AI-driven analytics tools can automatically sift through large volumes of HR data to identify patterns and make recommendations for optimizing employee performance (Jain et al., 2020). Additionally, the use of AI in recruitment is growing, allowing companies to reduce biases and improve candidate selection processes (Vrontis, Christofi, & Pereira, 2020).

Organizations are also increasingly focused on employee experience (EX) analytics, which goes beyond measuring engagement to assessing the holistic experiences of employees at every stage of their journey within the company. EX analytics allows firms to design more personalized and fulfilling work environments, which can lead to higher employee satisfaction and loyalty (Bassi et al., 2020).

Research Design

This research adopts a descriptive and correlational research design to describe the current state of HR analytics practices across different industries and to examine the relationships between HR analytics implementation and organizational performance outcomes.

Research Approach

A mixed-methods approach is employed, combining quantitative and qualitative data. The quantitative data is collected through surveys and organizational data related to HR analytics and performance outcomes. The qualitative data is obtained through semi-structured interviews with HR professionals and managers to gain deeper insights into the challenges and opportunities presented by HR analytics.

Data Collection Methods

A structured questionnaire was designed to gather quantitative data from HR professionals, managers, and executives across various industries. The survey focused on HR analytic usage, key metrics, and the perceived impact on performance indicators such as employee productivity, engagement, and retention. A Likert scale (1-5) was used to measure perceptions on the impact of HR analytics.  The survey targeted a sample size of approximately 150-200 respondents from companies with varying levels of HR analytics adoption (small, medium, and large enterprises). Data on KPIs such as employee turnover rates, engagement scores, productivity metrics, and financial performance will be collected from company reports and records, where available. This data will allow for an empirical evaluation of how HR analytics influences key performance outcomes.

In-depth interviews were conducted with a select group of HR leaders and managers (approximately 10-15 respondents) to explore their experiences with implementing HR analytics. The interviews focused on how organizations use HR analytics for decision-making, the benefits and challenges encountered, the impact of HR analytics on organizational culture and performance and future trends in HR analytics, including the integration of AI and machine learning. Purposive sampling was used to select interviewees who have direct involvement in HR analytics and decision-making.

Sampling Strategy

• Quantitative Sample

• Population: HR professionals, managers, and executives from organizations of varying sizes and industries.

Sampling Method: Stratified random sampling will be used to ensure diversity in the sample, covering organizations with different levels of HR analytics maturity.

Sample Size: Approximately 150-200 respondents for the survey.

Qualitative Sample

• Population: HR leaders and professionals directly involved in HR analytics implementation and decision-making.

• Sampling Method: Purposive sampling will be used to select participants who have experience with HR analytics.

• Sample Size: 10-15 participants for in-depth interviews.

Data Analysis

• Quantitative Analysis

• Descriptive Statistics: Mean, median, and standard deviation will be calculated to summarize the survey data and describe the adoption of HR analytics across organizations.

• Correlation Analysis: To examine the relationships between HR analytics practices and performance outcomes such as employee engagement, retention, and productivity.

• Regression Analysis: Multiple regression analysis will be conducted to evaluate the impact of various HR analytics metrics (e.g., recruitment, retention, training) on organizational performance KPIs. This analysis will help determine which aspects of HR analytics contribute most significantly to performance improvements.

Qualitative Analysis

• Thematic Analysis: The interview data will be transcribed and coded to identify common themes, patterns, and insights. This analysis will focus on understanding the challenges, benefits, and future potential of HR analytics as perceived by HR professionals.

• Triangulation: By combining the quantitative survey data with qualitative interview insights, the study aims to cross-validate findings and provide a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of HR analytics on organizational performance.

Reliability test

The reliability of the survey instrument is critical to ensure that the responses consistently measure the intended variables. For this study, Cronbach’s Alpha is used to assess the internal consistency of the items in the survey related to HR analytics usage and its impact on organizational performance (e.g., employee engagement, retention, productivity, financial performance).

Cronbach’s Alpha values typically range between 0 and 1, where:

• ≥ 0.9: Excellent reliability

• 0.8 – 0.9: Good reliability

• 0.7 – 0.8: Acceptable reliability

• 0.6 – 0.7: Questionable reliability

• < 0.6: Poor reliability

Table 1: Reliability Test

The above table 1 showcases that the Cronbach's Alpha values for most of the constructs in this study range from 0.76 to 0.91, indicating good to excellent reliability. This suggests that the survey instrument is consistent in measuring HR analytics usage and its impact on organizational performance. Constructs like employee productivity and financial performance, while acceptable, may benefit from further refinement to improve their reliability.

Table 2: Descriptive Statistics Table

* HR Analytics Usage Score is measured on a Likert scale where 1 = Not used at all, 5 = Fully integrated.

The descriptive statistics table 2 reveals that the mean score of 3.8 (on a 5-point Likert scale) suggests that most organizations have moderately integrated HR analytics into their practices. The variability (standard deviation of 0.95) shows a wide range of adoption levels across organizations. 60% of the surveyed organizations use predictive analytics, while 45% have adopted prescriptive analytics. This suggests that many organizations are still in the early stages of using advanced forms of analytics. On average, organizations make decisions using HR data 2.4 times per week. This indicates that HR analytics is becoming a routine part of decision-making in most organizations, though not yet fully embedded.

Table 3: CORRELATION MATRIX

The correlation matrix (table 3) shows strong positive correlations between HR analytics usage and key performance outcomes. There is a strong positive relationship between the use of HR analytics and employee engagement (0.75). This suggests that data-driven approaches to talent management, employee feedback, and performance evaluation can significantly boost engagement. Productivity (0.72) and Retention (0.60) also show strong positive correlations with HR analytics, indicating that organizations leveraging HR analytics see improvements in employee productivity and are better able to retain their HR analytics positively impacts financial performance (0.62), showing that data-driven HR practices contribute to better overall business results.

Table 4: Regression Analysis

The regression analysis results provide deeper insights into the strength of relationships between HR analytics and performance outcomes:

• Employee Engagement (B = 0.65, p < 0.001): HR analytics has a significant positive effect on employee engagement, with a high t-value of 6.50, meaning this relationship is not due to random chance.

• Employee Retention (B = 0.55, p < 0.002): Predictive analytics usage is a strong predictor of employee retention, explaining 45% of the variance in retention rates. This highlights the importance of using analytics to forecast turnover and implement retention strategies.

• Productivity (B = 0.72, p < 0.001): The effect of HR data integration on employee productivity is substantial, with HR analytics explaining 50% of the variance in productivity levels.

• Financial Performance (B = 0.48, p = 0.015): While the effect of HR analytics on financial performance is positive, it is less strong than the effects on other variables, indicating that financial outcomes are influenced by additional factors beyond HR analytics.

Qualitative Analysis - Thematic Analysis Table (Challenges of HR Analytics Implementation)

The thematic analysis from the qualitative interviews reveals the key challenges organizations face when implementing HR analytics:

• Data Literacy (mentioned by 12 out of 15 respondents): A significant challenge is the lack of data literacy within HR teams, with many struggling to interpret and leverage data effectively.

• Data Integration Challenges (10 respondents): Many organizations face difficulties in combining data from different HR functions, limiting their ability to use analytics holistically.

• Organizational Resistance (8 respondents): Resistance to adopting data-driven approaches is common, especially among senior management who are skeptical of relying solely on analytics for decision-making.

• Privacy and Compliance Issues (9 respondents): Concerns over data privacy and compliance with regulations like GDPR are prominent, as handling sensitive employee data requires stringent protocols.

Despite the benefits of HR analytics, challenges such as low data literacy, difficulties in data integration, and concerns over data privacy are major barriers to successful implementation. Overcoming these obstacles is crucial for organizations to fully realize the potential of HR analytics.

This study explored the impact of HR analytics on enhancing organizational performance, particularly focusing on key metrics such as employee engagement, retention, productivity, and financial performance. The empirical findings highlight that organizations adopting HR analytics experience significant improvements in these areas, suggesting that data-driven HR practices play a crucial role in organizational effectiveness.

HR analytics usage is positively correlated with improvements in employee engagement and retention, as data-driven decision-making allows organizations to better understand workforce trends and tailor strategies to enhance the employee experience. The use of predictive analytics within HR functions, such as recruitment and talent management, shows a direct impact on employee productivity and financial performance (ROI), demonstrating the value of forecasting workforce needs and optimizing resource allocation.

However, despite the advantages, barriers to HR analytics adoption remain. These include challenges related to data literacy among HR professionals, difficulties in integrating HR data across different platforms, and concerns over data privacy and compliance with regulations such as GDPR. These challenges need to be addressed for organizations to fully capitalize on the potential of HR analytics. Moreover, qualitative insights from HR professionals suggest that while HR analytics has a clear impact on improving decision-making, there is often organizational resistance to adopting data-driven practices. Overcoming this cultural resistance is essential for embedding analytics within HR functions. Furthermore, the integration of advanced technologies such as AI and machine learning in HR analytics holds the potential to further enhance decision-making, allowing organizations to transition from descriptive to predictive and prescriptive analytics.

Organizations that effectively integrate HR analytics into their processes are likely to see measurable improvements in performance outcomes. As HR analytics continues to evolve, it is imperative for organizations to build data literacy, improve data integration, and address privacy concerns to unlock the full potential of analytics-driven decision-making. Future research can explore the long-term impact of HR analytics on organizational strategy, as well as the role of emerging technologies in shaping the future of HR management.

Recommendations

1. Training HR professionals to understand and work with data is critical to making HR analytics more effective.
2.  Organizations should invest in platforms that enable seamless integration of data across various HR functions for a holistic view of workforce dynamics.
3.  HR teams must ensure that they adhere to legal regulations concerning employee data privacy to build trust and avoid compliance risks.
4. Organizations should work to overcome resistance to analytics by demonstrating its value through small, impactful use cases and gaining buy-in from leadership.
5.  Future HR strategies should incorporate AI and machine learning to move beyond reactive decision-making and toward proactive, predictive workforce planning.

LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

1. As HR analytics is a relatively new field, there may be a bias in the sample towards larger organizations or industries that have already adopted advanced analytics practices.
2. Gaining access to sensitive organizational performance data may prove challenging, particularly for smaller firms.
3. Survey responses may be subject to self-reporting bias, with respondents potentially overestimating the positive impact of HR analytics.

PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

The findings of this research on the impact of HR analytics on organizational performance offer several practical implications for HR professionals, business leaders, and organizations as a whole. By understanding how HR analytics can improve employee engagement, retention, productivity, and overall financial performance, companies can better harness the power of data-driven decision-making. The positive relationship between HR analytics usage and key performance outcomes—such as employee engagement, retention, and productivity—highlights the importance of data-driven HR practices. Organizations can leverage analytics to improve employee engagement by using real-time data to identify and address employee concerns, predict engagement trends, and develop personalized strategies for workforce development. They boost retention rates by analyzing turnover trends and predictive modeling to anticipate high-risk employees, allowing HR teams to implement retention strategies before valuable talent is lost. Also enhance productivity by tracking performance metrics and identifying bottlenecks or areas for improvement in employee performance, enabling organizations to allocate resources more effectively.

The study shows that organizations using more advanced forms of HR analytics—such as predictive and prescriptive analytics—tend to experience greater performance benefits. This suggests that organizations should invest in advanced analytics tools that allow for sophisticated data analysis, such as AI-driven solutions for workforce forecasting, talent acquisition, and performance management. Integrate analytics into existing HR platforms to streamline data from various HR functions (e.g., recruitment, learning and development, performance management) for holistic decision-making.

The research highlights organizational resistance as a significant barrier to HR analytics adoption. This resistance often stems from skepticism about the effectiveness of data-driven decision-making or fear of changing established processes. To overcome this, organizations should build a data-driven culture by providing training for HR professionals and leadership on the value of HR analytics, emphasizing how it leads to better decision-making and improved business outcomes. Pilot analytics projects that show measurable benefits in specific areas (e.g., reducing employee turnover or improving engagement) can help build trust in analytics-driven practices across the organization.

One of the key challenges identified in the study is the lack of data literacy among HR professionals, which can limit the effective use of analytics. To address this, organizations should invest in upskilling HR teams by providing training on data analysis, visualization, and interpretation skills. This ensures that HR staff are equipped to use analytics tools effectively. Establish cross-functional teams that pair HR professionals with data scientists or IT specialists to bridge the gap between HR expertise and technical analytics capabilities.

The study highlights that many organizations face challenges related to data integration and privacy concerns. These barriers must be addressed to fully implement HR analytics organizations should invest in integrated HR platforms that allow seamless data flow between various HR functions (e.g., recruitment, payroll, performance management) and across departments to create a unified view of workforce data. To mitigate privacy risks, organizations must ensure that they comply with relevant regulations (e.g., GDPR), implement robust data protection protocols, and clearly communicate to employees how their data will be used and safeguarded.

HR analytics can help bridge the gap between HR functions and broader organizational strategy by aligning talent management with business goals. This means HR teams should work closely with top management to ensure that workforce insights derived from analytics are aligned with the organization's strategic priorities. Analytics can be used to identify key drivers of business performance (e.g., high-performing teams, leadership effectiveness), allowing organizations to better target investments in talent development and resource allocation. HR analytics should be viewed as a strategic tool that provides valuable insights for aligning workforce management with long-term business objectives, helping organizations gain a competitive advantage. Using HR analytics to track and analyze employee sentiment, feedback, and performance can provide valuable insights into how to improve the employee experience. This leads to higher engagement and lower turnover, as analytics can predict when employees are likely to disengage and recommend interventions, such as career development opportunities or changes to working conditions. Measure the impact of HR initiatives on employee satisfaction, providing evidence for decisions about workplace policies, compensation, and benefits. HR teams should leverage analytics to continuously monitor and improve the employee experience, using data to make timely adjustments that foster engagement and satisfaction.

1. Angrave D, Charlwood A, Kirkpatrick I, Lawrence M, Stuart M. HR and analytics: why HR is set to fail the big data challenge. Hum Resour Manag J. 2016;26(1):1-11.
2. Fitz-enz J. The New HR Analytics: Predicting the Economic Value of Your Company’s Human Capital Investments. New York: AMACOM; 2010.
3. Marler JH, Boudreau JW. An evidence-based review of HR Analytics. Int J Hum Resour Manag. 2017;28(1):3-26.
4. Rasmussen T, Ulrich D. Learning from practice: How HR analytics avoids being a management fad. Organ Dyn. 2015;44(3):236-42.
5. Bassi L, Carpenter R, McMurrer D. Predictive analytics: What’s it good for? Harv Bus Rev.
6. Jain V, Khan N, Singh S. The future of HR analytics: Trends and opportunities. J Appl Manag Invest. 2020;9(3):155-68.
7. Minbaeva DB. Building effective HR analytics capabilities. Int J Hum Resour Manag. 2018;29(4):14-24.
8. Vrontis D, Christofi M, Pereira V. Artificial intelligence, robotics, advanced technologies, and human resource management: A review. 2020;122:102601.
9. Reddy PR, Keerthi PL. HR Analytics – An Effective Evidence Based HRM Tool. Int J Bus Manag Invent. 2017;6(7).
10. Sharma A, Sharma T. HR analytics and performance appraisal system: A conceptual framework for employee performance improvement. Manag Res Rev. 2017;40(6).
11. Anita R, Sumathi N. A study on the measuring the factors of HR analytics on performances management in services sector of selected companies in Chennai. JAC J Compos Theory. 2019;12(12).
12. Kailash U, Prathyusha M. HR Analytics Methodical Measurement of HR Processes. Int J Innov Sci Res Technol. 2020;5(11).
13. Opatha HHDJP. HR Analytics: A Literature Review and New Conceptual Model. Int J Sci Res Publ. 2020;10(6).
14. Said M, Khan I, Hameed F. The impact of performance management system on employees' performance. Int J Bus Manag Sci. 2021;2.
15. McCartney S, Fu N. Bridging the gap: why, how and when HR analytics can impact organizational performance. Manag Decis. 2022;60(13).
16. Ramzi B, Elrayah M. The Reasons that Affect the Implementation of HR Analytics among HR Professionals. Can J Bus Inf Stud. 2021;2. Available from: https://doi.org/10.34104/cjbis.021.029037